I
saw my brother Barry the other night. It'd been a while since I'd
seen him, except in my dreams.
You see, Barry
was killed almost 30 years ago. How, why�it almost doesn't matter
any more. He's gone, and his family and his friends still miss him;
still think of him almost every day.
At least I do.
But thinking about him, and remembering him as my wise and calming
older brother, is not the same as seeing him�something I thought
I'd never be able to do again.
That is, until
this videotape arrived in the mail.
I had helped to
MC a tribute to Bay Area Chinese-American television pioneers, produced
by the Chinese Historical Society, a few months ago. One of those
pioneers, Christopher Chow, who was a reporter for KPIX-TV in San
Francisco in the early '70s, produced a video salute to his fellow
broadcasters. The pacesetters included Willie Kee, Mario Machado,
Felicia Lowe, Linda Shen, Linda Yu, Vic Lee, Sam Chu Lin and AsianConnections.com's
co-founder, Suzanne Kai.
Stationed backstage,
I couldn't see the video, so I called Chris and asked for a copy.
He sent it�but, to my shock, added an extra half-hour or so of other
material. He had done a report on Chinatown on KPIX in 1972, he
told me, and, among others, he had interviewed my brother Barry,
a probation officer and youth worker. Chris thought I might like
to have the report.
Tape in machine,
I forgot all about those broadcasters. I fast-forwarded to Chris'
news reports, and, soon enough, found Barry.
It was a simple, minute-or-so interview.
He was straight forward, serious, talking about youths' frustrations
in Chinatown. There was nothing personal about it. He was just another
talking head, edited down to what the report needed, then eclipsed
by the next talking head.
But it was Barry.
I'd only had photographs and memories since June 26, 1972. Here,
now, was a moving image. I hit rewind and watched him again. His
voice, I'd always remembered, was lower than mine, and tinged with
an accent. On video, it still was. Although he was 29 when he was
murdered, he'd always remained my older brother. Now, watching him
in the year 2000, it was harder for me to think of him that way.
But that's only imagery at work. The fact is, he will always be
my big brother.
I said as much
in an article I wrote in 1984 for the San Francisco Chronicle.
At that point, it had been a dozen years since his death, and I
had never written about it.
I found the process
difficult and exhausting, but freeing. The resulting story led to
an invitation from the editor of Parade magazine to write
a similar piece. I received letters from around the country, from
people who, however they'd lost a loved one, felt a bond with me,
and taught me a lesson about the universality of familial loss.
One of the correspondents, I recall, was Ken Kesey, telling me about
his unending grief for his son.
That article in
Parade ultimately led to my memoir, The Rice Room.
Here's the original
article, from the June 26, 1984 edition of the Chronicle:
A Murder That Won't Go Away
Tonight, around
11:40 p.m., it will be 12 years since my family and I lost my older
brother Barry.
He was shot down
at the door of his apartment in the Sunset District in San Francisco.
He was a probation officer who worked with black kids in Richmond
jntil 1971, when he learned about a job in Chinatown, as the director
of a youth center. He was, in a sense, coming home to his own people.
On June 27, 1972,
The Chronicle's story began: "A brilliant and respected youth
worker has become the 10th known victim in a series of
Chinatown gangland slayings." There were reportedly two assailants;
the case was never solved, and my parents forbade me from doing
any personal investigation for fear of my safety.
All we have are
two bittersweet anniversaries, on May 8th, his birthday,
and on June 26th, his death. And, of course, memories.
But I have something
more. Over 12 years, there have been few days when I haven't thought
of Barry. And although the pain has lessened over the years, there
are indelible thoughts and images, not connected as much with my
brother as with his death.
He was 29 when
he was killed. I was 27. Now, whenever I think of him, he is still
my older brother. He is perennially wiser than me. In our silent
conversations, he has advice for me; it is usually calming.
I don't remember
much about the wake, except that my mother wept as I'd never seen
her weep before�We handed out copies of one of Barry's favorite
drawings, by artist Ben Shahn, with the legend: "You have not converted
a man because you have silenced him."
I devoured newspaper
stories about gangs. Although it pained me that I couldn't explore
the case, I was fascinated by others. I stopped at every name mentioned,
wondering.
I looked on people
as possible surrogate older brothers. I remember the brother of
a girlfriend, a roommate, a fellow writer, a male Chinese friend.
But that was just wishful non-thinking. By Chinese tradition, I
was now the older brother of the family.
I am unable to
listen to Bach, especially to pieces that were on an album called
A New Sound From the Japanese Bach Scene. That was one of
his favorite records, and we played it at his wake. Whenever I come
across it, I have to tune out or walk away.
Besides Bach,
I find it difficult to listen to Elton John's "Daniel" ("�my brother,
you are older than me, do you still feel the pain?).
We were both,
in our own ways, rebellious. Born into Chinese traditions, into
a hard work ethic, we did our duties and earned good grades, but
managed to upset our parents with our independence. He dated girls
who weren't Chinese, and he studied not law or medicine, but criminology.
I told my parents I'd rather be a disc jockey than a dentist.
Years later,
Barry's loss inspired the bridging of a lifelong language barrier
between my folks and me. With help from a family friend, I was able
to interview them about their lives in China; their courtship by
mail; the beginnings of our family in Oakland. I still haven't asked
them about Barry. If he enters my mind every day, he must enter
theirs almost every hour.
Thinking about
him and now, for the first time, writing about losing him, shakes
me up. The family of any victim of senseless, sudden death knows
that it isn't easy being a survivor.
Someday, I want
to be able to listen to Bach and connect it with Barry's life, not
his death. That would make the music beautiful again for me
Christopher
Chow, producer of the Chinese American Historical Society's
"Broadcast Pioneers" video salute, also wrote "Casting
Our Voices," a ground-breaking history of Asian American broadcast
pioneers, reprinted exclusively here with permission.
Ben Fong-Torres, long-time writer
and editor at Rolling Stone magazine, is the author of four books,
including his memoirs, The Rice Room: Growing Up Chinese-American,
and his latest, Not Fade Away: A Backstage Pass to 20 Years of Rock
& Roll. He is Editorial Director of myplay.com, an Internet
music site that offers free Web space, where users can grab, store,
mix, play, and share music of all kinds.
Click to Ben Fong-Torres Articles
Index
Visit Ben's official site: www.BenFongTorres.com
|